Buy the bottle once
The lotion and the foaming hand soap both come in refill sizes that fill their dispensers four times over. It costs less per ounce and keeps three empty bottles out of the waste stream every time.
Both come in the full range of scents, including Pure and Simple Unscented. If you're starting from scratch rather than reusing a pump you already own, the glass dispensers and the sink-side tray are here too.
The foaming soap needs a foaming pump specifically. A standard lotion pump won't produce the lather. Made in small batches in Vermont.
What it works out to
The 32 oz foaming soap refill is $28 and fills an 8 oz dispenser four times. That's $7 a refill against $11.50 for a new bottle.
The 24 oz lotion refill fills the 6 oz bottle four times over.